Your Go-To Spot for Homemade NY-Style Pizza
Authentic New York Flavor Since 1987
At New York Pizzeria, we don’t just make pizza—we craft edible masterpieces, one cheesy, crispy, delicious slice at a time. Proudly serving Jacksonville, NC, we bring you the real-deal, foldable, New York-style pizza that dreams are made of.
With over 38 years of experience (and a whole lot of flour-covered aprons), we make our pasta and pizza dough from scratch every single day. Fresh ingredients, classic recipes, and a whole lot of love have made us a local favorite for anyone craving an authentic taste of New York—no plane ticket required.
ORDER NOW
Pressing ‘Order’ is scientifically proven to increase happiness.
PIZZA
SUBS
ITALIAN FAVORITES
“This pizza place has great food and service. Far superior in quality, price, and atmosphere to the pizza chain around the corner!”
Caroline M, Local Guide
“I love lasagna right? I even love frozen lasagna TV dinners! But their lasagna is homemade by one of their lovely employees and it happens to be the best that I have ever eaten in my entire life! Keep up the good work you guys! You are my go-to restaurant whenever I've had a long hard day at work and don't feel like cooking.”
Jessica R, Regular Customer
“New York Pizzeria is my go-to local spot for some pizza. But did doesn't stop there they have it all, pizza by the slice, banging cheesesteaks, sandwiches and so much more. I've been coming here for 10 + years and never had a bad experience. I typically go with the Manhattan Pizza which has Alfredo sauce, grilled chicken, spinach....this thing is killer”
David P, Local Guide